The scope of services expected in terms of the City of Tshwane Tshwane Bon Accord
Quarry. The professional advisory service required is divided into three phases,
namely;
PHASE 1A: Preparatory Phase (Issue RFQ to the Market for a Transaction Advisor
to submit documents setting out the extent to which it meets the requirements to be
appointed as Transaction Advisory Service provider - the scope is outlined below with
its associated activities).
PHASE 1B: CoT selects the transaction advisory service provider and only reveals
the top bidder who complied or passed all stages of evaluation.. The bid will be
awarded to the highest scoring bidder in terms of the applicable preference points
system. The lowest bidder by price may not necessarily be appointed if the
functionality requirements do not meet the minimum requirements of functionality.
PHASE 2: Request for Qualification - Under direction of CoT and the support of the
TA issue a RFQ (Issuing a Request for Qualification to the market and coordinating
the assessment of the qualified bidders. scope below activities are associated with this
phase). Only bidders meet the minimum requirements may proceed to the proposal
phase of the bid.
A priced proposal with deliverables and timelines which corresponds with the scope
of work below must be submitted This form should be completed as indicated.
Phase 3: Request for Proposals: Only the top five bidders (top qualifying bidders) to
make proposals as to the nature of the Contractual Agreement, the key requirements
and determinants of the contract, the key dependencies and guarantees and minimum
standards. A best and alternate bidder will be selected to proceed to financial close
out and contractual formulation and submission of guarantees.
7.1 INCEPTION REPORT
The inception report should describe the understanding and interpretation of the
service provider’s plan of action or approach which will cover key elements as
indicated in the Terms of Reference. In addition, this will cover timelines required for
conducting the business case or plan. Further information to enhance this approach
will be considered.
DELIVERABLE 1 – INCEPTION REPORT
7.2 Supply and Demand Analysis for the Gauteng Market
The market supply and demand analysis gives definition to the quarry operations,
preparing the way for the technical solution options analysis. This should, demonstrate
that the project aligns with the municipality’s strategic pillars / objectives and IDPs.
Identify and analyse the required operational and capital budget to extract the
maximum returns of the facility.
The market analysis needs to explore the market and the sectors that are pertinent to
the quarry. The demand for quarry products in South Africa and specifically Gauteng
and immediate surrounding provinces and municipalities is mainly driven by the
construction industry, which is comprised of residential building, non-residential
building, and civil construction. The market analysis should incorporate appropriate
industry benchmarks and highlight best international practices that are applicable for
this operation. In specific, assess the implementation of relevant similar type of quarry
operations in South Africa from both a private and public sector perspective. Also, to
conduct market sounding exercise, where the needs to understand the private sector’s
value drivers and the main financial and operational constraints companies might face
during the provision of infrastructure and services.
DELIVERABLE 2 – MARKET PROJECTION ANALYSIS OF THE PROPOSED
PRODUCT SCHEDULE
7.3 EONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
This report must provide a broad based economic model based on the supply and
demand analysis provided in report 1. The soundness of the proposed investment int
the quarry development is premised on an understanding of the demand for
construction materials. Modelling must set out various scenarios based on the current
and potential demand for materials using a basket of assumptions that are sustainable
and realistic. This report should be accompanied by financial modelling on capital and
operating budget estimates and estimated revenues linked to a three-mode
assessment. The report must cover a low viability level, middle viability level and high
viability level scenario to establish commercial viability of the proposed quarry
development. A break-even model could also be included to help determine the most
appropriate cause of action. The financials should cover NPV, IRR, and ROI, Payback
period, debt to equity ratios, current and additional revenue streams An economic
impact assessment report can be included to reflect the investment value, direct and
indirect job creation, and contribution to the broader gross geographic product.
DELIVERABLE 3 – LEGAL AND TECHNICAL DUE DILIGENCE REPORT
7.4 LEGAL DUE DELLIGENCE
The legal and regulatory analysis will include a review of the Legal Frameworks that
may impact the implementation of the project. This will include South African
Legislation (National, Provincial, Local) as well as Regulations governing Legislatures.
This should cover; legal issues, site enablement issues including the following (land
ownership, land availability and any title deed endorsements, potential land claims,
Lease interests in the land, land consolidation and classification, zoning rights and
town planning requirements). In addition, this should analyse suitable procurement
legislation. Investigate and indicate applicable mining legislation for the quarry. The
quarries are compliant with the DMRE and DEFFE requirements and regular testing
and assessments are conducted to ensure it meets the requirements. Bidders must
demonstrate an understanding of the Minerals Acts, Environmental authorisations and
SHEQ compliance requirements. The nature and form of the operating entity can also
be included in this analysis and proposals may be considered part of the bidders’
submission.
DELIVERABLE 4 – STAKEHOLDER IDENTIFICATION AND ENGAGEMENT
REPORT
7.5 STAKEHOLDER ANALYSIS
The Transaction Advisor shall identify and conduct an overview of the stakeholders
likely to be involved in the quarry development. Engagement with different
stakeholders is crucial. A stakeholder engagement plan of consultation guided by
relevant legislation or policies must be supplied in principle setting out the
identification of stakeholders as well as linking stakeholders to the various prescripts
in legislation which require compulsory public participation and engagement. A report
identifying the parties more broadly, but where possible with a degree of specificity to
ensure all consultation channels are pursued satisfactorily.
DELIVERABLE 5 – ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS REPORT
7.6 FINANCIAL AND ECONOMIC DUE DILLIGENCE
The CoT will make available the annual quarry report for the 24/25 financial year. The
city has valued the assets (plant and equipment) at R 241 million. This does not include
a value for the quarry body. The operating annual budget is R 57 million which includes
provisions for depreciation and rehabilitation. The annual report will also reflect the
current outputs and staff capacity. It also contains estimated production capacity if the
quarry were to operate longer hours. A variety of investment scenarios will be included
which the city conducted.
DELIVERABLE 6 – RISK ASSESSMENT AND MITIGATION REPORT
7.7 RISK ASSESMENT
The TA and the CoT task team will conduct comprehensive risks assessment of the
development, the operating entity and the activity itself at the quarries. This triple risk
assessment seeks to identify operator risks which may and can be placed in the
Operator SLA to address over the duration of the project. The risks which emanate
from the legal compliance which may and can have the effect of a complete shutdown
of activities. And lastly the risks to the quarry itself. The risk viability assessment is
critical to ensure the continuation of the project. These risks are critical to the
conditions which are required to ensure a successful operation. This should consider
all relevant risks of the project. A risk matrix and register should be developed.
DELIVERABLE 7 – PROPOSED PROCUREMENT PLAN FOR THE QUARRIES
REPORT
7.8 PROCUREMENT PLAN
The procurement plan must set out the preferred methodology or modality which the
CoT wants to implement. The CoT have the following known choices to select from in
the procurement or implementation of this decision.
1. Section 14 (MFMA) – Release of an asset no longer required for municipal
purposes. This may be a necessary first step in releasing the asset. However,
the city will staill draw materials from the asset and so it may be contradictory
for the city to proceed with this mode if it cannot state that it no longer requires
the asset for municipal purposes.
2. Section 33 (MFMA) – Contracts for longer than 3 years. While this section is
admittedly only for the purchase of goods and services for more than 3 years,
it does provide some leeway as a tool for the release of this land for this
purpose. The city intends or wishes to make the quarries available for a 20-
year agreement. The city also intends to make use of quarry materials for the
same period. It therefore provides a tool for consideration.
3. Section 78 (Municipal Systems Act) – The option to create a company or a
municipal entity to hold the asset off the city’s balance sheet may also be
considered. This may be a better alternative to the much lengthier process of a
PPP. The operational entity proposed by the bidder may wish to simplify its
operation and not be subjected to the MFMA and its many limitations.
4. Section 12 MFMA PPP – Section 120 is a lengthy and onerous process which
may be considered but may not result in an expedient outcome for the city.
5. There are other options which may and can be considered.
The TA may and must provide a schedule of the pros and cons of each scenario and
may make suggestions and proposals as to the entity form that is both progressive
and quick to bring to operation.
DELIVERABLE 8 – PROCUREMENT PLAN REPORT WITH RFQ AND RFP
7.9 PARTICIPATE IN COMMITTEES
The TA is expected to participate in the Bid Specification Committee (BSC) and Bid
Evaluation Committee (BEC) established to process the bids. Professional technical
TA members should form part of the team. The TA will participate in the two stages.
The request for qualification process to select the top bidders. The Top Bidders will
continue to the Request for Proposal stage. From this process the best and alternate
bidder will be selected.
DELIVERABLE 9 – DRAFT CLOSE OUT REPORT AND DRAFT CONTRACT
AGREEMENTS
The TA is required to assist in drafting the report to close out the RFQ and RFP
process which will form part of the record of decision in this regard. As part of the close
out report the TA will provide an indication of a minimum set of terms and conditions
for the primary contract and SLA between CoT and the preferred bidder.
DELIVERABLE 10 – MINUTES AND NOTES OF ALL SCM COMMITTEE
MEETINGS
7.10 PARTICIPATE IN NEGOTIATIONS
The TA is expected to participate in contract negotiations.
DELIVERABLE 11 – Record of all Project MANAGEMENT MEETINGS NOTES
AND MINUTES
The TA will provide a record of all project and process management meetings. This
will form the record of engagement and is required to be submitted along with the
milestone reports.
DELIVERABLE 12 – PUBLIC PARTICIPATION MEETINGS
7.11 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
The TA in consultation with the City shall arrange the Public Participation or
Consultation where necessary. It is proposed that at least 2 public participation
session be held with both interested and affected parties as well as a broader
engagement session with the business sector. These sessions are outside the scope
of the legislated sessions which will be governed by SCM processes.
8. MANAGEMENT OF THE TRANSACTION ADVISOR
8.1 A TA should nominate a liaison(s) who is an experienced professional(s) to
manage the TA team. A professional should coordinate the activities of various
TA team members.
8.2 The COT representative GH ROC will establish a project team (Project Steering
Committee) to engage regularly in accordance with the work plan and schedule
with the TA to efficiently complete the various delivery items. The Project
Steering Committee will meet at least monthly, and the TA’s liaison (s) will
report progress at these meetings. Critical milestones will form part of the
discussion and must meet the CoT requirements.
9. REPORTING
9.1 In addition to the above, meetings will be scheduled to coincide with the key
deliverables of the TA in the delivery of the project.
9.2 The COT representative GH ROC, after consultation with the City of Tshwane-
Chief Operation Office (COO), will confirm that the TA has satisfactorily
completed each deliverable before invoices can be submitted for payment or
compensation to be approved.
9.3 A workplan with a schedule of meetings, report deliverables, process
dependencies and milestone deadlines will be submitted and agreed upon
betweetheeh CoT and the TA. The representatives will agree to coordinate
meetings, inputs to reports, and presentations and manage and meetthe project
deliverables deadlines, unless agree to otherwise.
9.4 The TA will submit milestone progress reports as may be agreed to describe
the progress of work and further planned actions, an updated work schedule,
and any key constraints encountered by the team in the performance of the
activities.
9.5 The milestone detailed progress report and presentation (Ms PowerPoint) in the
following format Microsoft Word, PDF is required.
9.6 The reports submitted by the TA will be approved within such a period as will
be agreed with COT – GH ROC, to ensure that no delay or disruption to the TA
activities. Reports will be submitted in respect of key deliverables for decision
making and approval.