Functionality evaluation: The minimum threshold score of 70 out of 100 must be achieved to qualify for further evaluation on the 80/20 preference points system. Criteria and weights: Overall Experience (40 points) - Company Experience in public sector internal audit (15 points), Reference Letters in public sector (5 points), Company Experience in SETA (15 points), Reference Letters in SETA (5 points); Project Plan and Methodology (10 points); Resources and allocation (40 points) - Resource Plan, Capacity and Financial Sustainability (10 points), Expertise and Capability of Staff (30 points); Quality Assurance and Improvement Programme (10 points).
Scoring for company experience in public sector internal audit: more than 15 years = 5 points, 12-15 years = 4, 10-12 years = 3, 8-10 years = 2, 5-8 years = 1, failure to substantiate = 0. Reference letters must be on official letterhead, relate to completed contracts within last 10 years, describe services and contract period, provide contactable reference person, and be from different institutions. Scoring: 5 or more letters = 5 points, 4 = 4, 3 = 3, 2 = 2, 1 = 1, none = 0.
Scoring for company experience in SETA environment: more than 15 years = 5 points, 12-15 = 4, 10-12 = 3, 8-10 = 2, 5-8 = 1, failure to substantiate = 0. Reference letters for SETA must meet same requirements as public sector letters and be from different SETAs. Scoring: 5 or more = 5, 4 = 4, 3 = 3, 2 = 2, 1 = 1, none = 0.
Project Plan and Methodology scoring: 5 points for addressing all five requirements (methodology, project plan, quality assurance, reporting arrangements, progress monitoring), 4 for four requirements, 3 for three, 2 for two, 1 for one, 0 for none or failure to submit.
Resource Plan, Capacity and Financial Sustainability scoring: 5 points for addressing all four sub-sections (resource plan and team structure, approach to resourcing, tools/methodologies/systems, financial sustainability), 3 for three, 2 for two, 1 for one, 0 for none or failure to substantiate.
Expertise and Capability of Staff scoring: Score each of six positions (Engagement Partner/Director, Senior Audit Manager, Internal Audit Manager, IT Specialist, Senior Internal Auditor, Internal Auditor) out of 5 points based on meeting minimum requirements and years of experience. For Internal Auditor position, score based on least experienced proposed auditor.
QAIP scoring: 5 points for documented QAIP aligned to Global Internal Audit Standards, internal quality reviews, monitoring and corrective actions, and readiness for external reviews; 3 for partial arrangements; 1 for minimal or ad hoc controls; 0 for failure to substantiate.
Pricing and preferential point system (80/20): Bidders achieving minimum 70% on functionality are evaluated on price and specific goals. 80 points for price, 20 for specific goals: Black People Ownership (100% = 5, 51% = 3, less than 51% = 0), Black Women Ownership (100-50% = 5, 49% and less = 0), Black Youth Ownership (100-50% = 5, 49% and less = 0), People with Disability Ownership (1 or more = 5, none = 0).
Summary of compliance and elimination reasons: Bidders must submit one Functionality and one Financial Proposal, otherwise disqualified. Bidders or directors/shareholders on the National Treasury Restricted List will be disqualified. Additional elimination criteria include failure to initial all pages, non-compliance with B-BBEE requirements, and missing VAT registration where applicable.